← muthari.com

Stage gates: the system says no

Muthari guides · for contractors who fabricate what they install

A stage gate is a rule a system enforces by refusing: the next step cannot be recorded until the step it depends on has been. A reminder is a message; a gate is a closed door. The difference matters because reminders are ignored under pressure and gates are not — when the crane is waiting, nobody reads the reminder, but nobody can dispatch a zone the system will not release. For a contractor who fabricates and installs, six gates carry most of the value: no take-off without an approved material submittal, no fabrication without an approved drawing and issued material, no dispatch without a QC pass, no inspection request before installation is complete, no handover without approved inspections, and no claim without an approved budget. The rest of this guide is that map, and how to live with it.

Gate or reminder? The test

Try to do the thing.

If the record is written and a warning follows, it was a reminder — the work proceeded and the system apologised. If the record is refused and the reason is shown, it was a gate. Most "approval workflows" fail this test: the dropdown still moves, the email goes out afterwards, and the audit trail is theatre.

A gate that a manager can switch off is also a reminder. Discipline that lives in a setting will be turned off the first week the site falls behind.

The gate map for a fabricate-and-install package

No take-off without an approved material submittal

Taking off quantities from an unapproved specification means buying material the consultant may reject. The gate holds procurement until the material is approved on the record. If the site genuinely cannot wait, the bypass must be recorded as a fact — who approved verbally, when — not hidden.

No fabrication without an approved drawing and issued material

The two most common ways to make scrap: cutting to a drawing that will change, and starting a zone whose material is still on a truck. The gate checks both on the zone before the first stage can be stamped.

No dispatch without QC

A zone that has not passed factory inspection cannot be put on a delivery note. Rejects go back through a recorded rework round, and the gate applies again on the next attempt.

No inspection request before installation is complete

Raising a work inspection request on a half-installed zone wastes the consultant's visit and earns a rejection. The gate waits for the installed quantity to reach the zone quantity, and for the material inspection to have been approved first.

No handover without approved inspections

Handover is the claim's foundation. The gate requires both the material and work inspections to be approved before the zone can be closed and locked.

No claim without an approved budget

Invoicing before the budget is approved means claiming against numbers nobody has signed. The gate blocks claim creation until the budget is locked, and re-checks after.

Living with gates

How Muthari OS handles this. All six gates above are enforced by refusal, and none is configurable. Take-off requires an approved material submittal, or a recorded verbal-approval bypass with the approver's name. Fabrication cannot be stamped on a zone without an approved drawing and issued material, and a superseded drawing stops further floor moves. Dispatch by delivery note is refused for any zone without a QC pass. A work inspection request requires the material inspection approved and installation complete; handover requires both inspections approved and then locks the record. Claims are blocked until the budget is approved. When a move is refused the reason is shown at the moment of the attempt. Two honest limits: starting installation before the material inspection is allowed but recorded as an "urgent start" fact rather than blocked, and a claim that exceeds the revised contract value raises a warning rather than a refusal. Approval routing — who signs a purchase order — is company policy and is configurable; the gates are not. Built by contractors in the trade.

Book a free demo  See the whole system →